I’m no Expert….
But here’s my opinion. Just as Americans vilified the Russians during the Cold War, it seems to me we’ve done the same with the Chinese. Fearing the country’s economic power, military might and Communist leadership we’ve assumed or been led to believe the Chinese people must be living lives of desperation.
Without excusing the regime’s terror tactics in Tibet for the past 60 years, or forgetting the inhuman working and living conditions of factory workers and poor farmers in the countryside, I have to say the people of Beijing don’t appear to be oppressed. In fact, the people we’ve met working in hotels and restaurants, playing with their children in public parks, and visiting their nation’s historical monuments appear to be living lives quite like ours in the West.
No doubt I’m only seeing the surface, but I expected a populace of unhappy drones. To the contrary, the cafes are filled with young women texting and taking pictures of each other with their smart phones, public spaces are jammed with Chinese families during weekdays–assumably on vacation, the restaurants and shops are filled with Chinese folks–Westerners are few and far between–and enough of an anomaly that several times a day parents will ask if they can take a picture of me with their child.
The point? What we’re seeing has more to do with class and economics than a political system, and the upwardly mobile Chinese middle class have more in common with most Americans than we could have imagined.
What’s more, as a metropolis, Beijing works–the roads are well maintained, the streets are clean, there doesn’t appear to be any unemployment, crime is nonexistent and people take pride in their work. In short, compared with many American cities, such as New York, for example, Beijing is in a lot better shape (If you’ve ever driven from NYC to LaGuardia airport, you know what I mean).
Which is a surprise to me, having swallowed enough propaganda concerning the evils of communism. As a young college educated woman we spoke with explained, she may not be able to vote, but she is able to make all other decisions about her life–what to study, what profession she will pursue, when to get married, where to live and how to spend her money.
Yes I know the press is controlled, and the state owns all the land, and couples can only have one child, and government critics are jailed, but even so, when compared to the quality of life, standard of living and lack of personal and political freedom of people living in the Middle East or Southeast Asia, the Northern Chinese at least, have it made.
Clearly American corporations have figured this out–there are KFCs on every other corner, Ford cars on the street, and Lay’s potato chips and Coca Cola in every street vendors wares. Just do the math: if you can sell your product to even 1 percent of 2 billion people your market is tremendous.
As the saying goes, because of their wealth (trade balance and debt holdings included), the Chinese are going to rule the world. I think it’s safe to say, there’s not as much to fear as we thought.

Finally some meat on these bones. I need to put two recent post together to get to the essense of what is going on here. While I love Barbara’s perspective of the Chinese people and wholeheartedly agree as really, we the people here in the good old USA are right there with the Chinese people as only wanting a good and healthy life for us and our loved ones. If it were only so simple!
Now I have to throw in Michael’s post “CON GAMES: Military-Industrial Complex @ 50″
What we are dealing with today is the convergence of this countries 50 year evolution of the M/I Complex and China’s monetary birth in a new milleneum.
The future of this unholy union is the concern for those fine Chinese citizens as well as for those of us here in the U.S. This is the crux before us today. Not whether we should be voting for a liberal or a conservative!
Those who wish to remain in the divide and conquer past will find the future a train wreck. As in, most likely they won’t know what hit them till its too late and the force….
If this gets by the censor it will give you a look at what is happening beyond the world of FOX, NBC, CBS, MSNBC, ABC, ROLLING STONE, VANITY FAIR, ETC!
The end of this movie shows what is happening in todays China below the surface of that glittering world Barbara describes. That is why I have to disagree with her on her last paragraph. There, like here, all is not as it seems.
“As the saying goes, because of their wealth (trade balance and debt holdings included), the Chinese are going to rule the world. I think it’s safe to say, there’s not as much to fear as we thought.”
Here is the link:
http://video.google.com/googleplayer.swf?docId=1070329053600562261&autoplay=1
I will end with Micheal’s closing line to “Military-Industrial Complex @ 50.”
“Put another way, the business of the military is business. Have another drink and get used to an idea that’s been around for fifty years.”
The fact remains that all of the competing systems–including Communism and Sharia Law–are woefully repressive and not even close to our American standards. It’s not that the Chinese are good or bad, or that Muslims don’t have hearts of gold, but that whatever good exists is nonetheless trapped within the unfriendly confines of hopelessly repressive systems. There’s not an American alive–or at least no one this side of your neighborhood mosque–who would trade places so as to be in societies where thought is repressed and/or women are eggregiously suppressed.
The best we can say, as Barbara says, is that a horrible system is not as bad as we thought. But would anyone, given a choice, want to live there?